Freight Broker vs Dispatcher: How to Tell the Difference

arial view of a truck on a highway surrounded by green fields

We've often discussed the different players in the trucking industry. There are several key parties in supply chain management, from shipping companies to trucking companies and owner operators.

Often, these players have very distinct but similar roles. It's always important to have the right team of freight management professionals on your side.

Take freight brokers and dispatchers, for example. They may perform similar tasks, but understanding the difference can help you make an informed decision as you choose the service you need.

Let's take a close look at freight brokers and dispatchers.

Freight Broker vs Dispatcher: Defining the Roles

a small child wearing a harvard t-shirt points to something on a laptop.

Freight brokers and dispatchers have specific roles that they fulfill within the trucking industry. Both help coordinate movements within the supply chain, but let's look at the differences between each one.

The Role of the Freight Broker

Freight brokers handle many responsibilities. Most importantly, freight brokers serve as a connection between carriers and shippers.

When shipping companies need to move loads from point A to point B, freight brokers connect those loads with the best cargo carrier for the job. Freight brokers build relationships with carriers and shippers to ensure on time delivery and smooth coordination.

They also have several other responsibilities, including negotiating rates, resolving issues, and tracking loads.

The Role of the Freight Dispatcher

Like freight brokers, dispatchers search load boards, communicate with shipping companies and trucking companies, and help maximize truck utilization.

That said, the biggest difference between a truck dispatcher and a freight brokerage is that freight brokers represent both the trucking company and the shipper, while dispatchers work with carriers. They are often employed directly by carriers, but many are independent dispatchers, operating on a contract basis.

Expertise and Resources

a pink coffee cup next to a book with the word “knowledge” on the spine

Freight brokers and dispatchers both have a lot of logistical expertise, but they also have some different skills and resources.

Freight Broker Expertise and Resources

Freight brokers specialize in finding the best match between shippers and carriers. They have to understand what makes a carrier the right choice for any particular load.

The right freight broker will also have a large network of carriers and shippers, a deep understanding of the market, and an up-to-date knowledge of current rates.

We've mentioned in the past that freight brokers must also have excellent communication skills, transparency, and reliable customer support.

A great freight broker is a great multitasker.

Dispatcher Expertise and Resources

Dispatchers also find loads, have great negotiation skills, and pay attention to details. Like a freight brokerage, a truck dispatch service will need plenty of skilled multitaskers on its team.

However, freight dispatcher resources are more closely tied to a single carrier rather than a broader network of carriers and shipping companies.

Time and Cost Efficiency

an analog alarm clock against a white background

Freight brokers and dispatchers also have some differences when it comes to time and cost efficiency.

Freight Broker Time and Cost Efficiency

Thanks to their large networks and expertise, freight brokers provide shipping companies with a wide range of motor carriers, which ensures efficient transportation industry solutions.

Because their services are so comprehensive, and because they work with both shippers and carriers, they help simplify each part of the logistics process.

This way, shippers and carriers alike can save time and resources, shifting their focus to other core aspects of their business.

Dispatcher Time and Cost Efficiency

Dispatchers, like brokers, save time by coordinating schedules and making real-time adjustments when unforeseen circumstances arrive.

However, because they limit their services to a single carrier or a few smaller carriers, businesses that use dispatchers alone may miss opportunities to secure the most cost-effective transportation choices, especially when those businesses have varied shipping needs or work within more than one geographic area.

Regulation and Compliance

a fountain pen laying on top of a sheet of paper

One of the most important differences between a freight broker and a dispatcher is that a freight broker needs to meet strict regulations in order to operate.

For one thing, the freight broker needs a license from the Federal Motor Carrier Safety Administration (FMCSA). For another, they must also be insured.

A dispatcher, on the other hand, does not have license or insurance requirements.